BACK

Champagne Style
When it comes to the great French Champagne houses, style means more than just fashion.


By Nancy Ross Ryan



Photo by Laurie Proffitt
Champagne has always been "in style." Since the late 1800s. Champagne has been the drink of fashion for coronations and celebrations, kings and commoners. But all Champagnes are not created equal, even though they are produced in the Champagne region of France by the traditional methode Champenoise pioneered there. What separates the great from the good, the superb from the satisfactory, the amazing from the adequate, is a matter of style. The great Champagne houses -- unlike the small growers or the cooperatives -- go to tremendous trouble and expense to produce wines that are not only more complex and more able to age than simpler Champagnes, but, through painstaking blending, make wines year after year that are consistent with their unique house "style."

I learned my first lesson in style this spring in Reims, France, from a Prince whose royal lineage dates from the 13th century. Prince Alain de Polignac (with degrees in engineering, chemistry and oenology) is the great, great grandson of Mme. Pommery who was widowed in 1858 and, of necessity, took over as head of the House of Pommery. She not only lead the house to greatness but, in 1875, created the world's first brut (dry) Champagne. As Pommery's oenologist, Prince Alain, for the past 25 years, has been blending the 40 selected crus of the three Champagne grape varieties that make Pommery Brut Royal. He describes the style as "Fresh, vivacious. A supple, fruity finish. A full-bodied but light structure," and adds, "No style, no Champagne." And, lest there be any doubt as to the importance he places on style, he says, "Different houses have different styles. But no style, no house." And he took me through a tasting of some of the still wines that will go into the next Brut Royal.

Only three grapes are allowed in Champagne: One white grape, Chardonnay, and two red grapes, Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier. But the still wines (some very austere) that I was tasting made from those grapes were a far cry from the bubbly, lively, elegant Champagne that would emerge after its second fermentation in the Champagne bottle. So Prince Alain described the contribution that the different wines make to the final product: "Pinot Meunier is very important, even though it is a small percentage. It adds something very fruity, supple, smooth and charming -- easy to understand. The Pinot Noir, in general, can give body and longevity. And Chardonnay, depending on the vineyard, gives freshness, purity, elegance." The first blend is always, he says, on paper, based on tasting and memory of the house style. Wines are added, subtracted. Next comes the big tasting in January of the year, and it can take a full month to finalize the blend. "We need all of February for bottling," he says. For him, the Brut Royal is the most important in the Pommery line of eight Champagnes. "The heart of the House of Pommery is the Brut Royal. For many people it's their first contact with Pommery," he says.

Back in Chicago, I was exploring my discovery of style with Steven Lande, general manager and sommelier of the Dining Room at the Ritz-Carlton, Chicago, a lover of and expert in Champagne. He confirmed that the great houses all had their styles, all different, all unique. And, he says, "The non-vintage Champagnes are the heart of style and of the house. It is their calling card -- and their bread and butter because more of these Champagnes are sold." "But is it worth it to spend a minimum of $30 and up to $90 a bottle for style?" I asked. "Oh yes!," he replied. "Champagne is very expensive to make. More labor goes into it. There is pressing, fermenting, blending, a second fermentation, aging for two to 30 years, riddling, disgorgement, and dosage -- all necessary steps to produce Champagne."

"So how," I asked, "can one discover the different styles?" "Not only by tasting, but by accompanying with food. Champagnes are great food wines, and often underused. Every one has a different connection, sometimes with food and sometimes before food as an aperitif," says Lande.

Steven Lande provided me with a head start by picking ten great houses, giving a thumbnail sketch of their styles as shown in their non-vintage (NV) brut Champagnes, along with some food suggestions:

  • BILLECART-SALMON BRUT NV $28; and ROSÉ BRUT NV $50: "For some reason this house often slips by critics and consumers. It's a house that truly should be in the upper echelon. Aggressive bubbles, but not overly so. Fruit and terroir are evident. I recommend it with smoked salmon, caviar, ceviches."

  • BOLLINGER GRAND ANNÉE NV BRUT $79:"Very different expressions of their house style are shown within their line. If you like toasty or biscuity aromas of mature champagne, this non-vintage is for you. I would want to eat it with cooked fish/shellfish. Shrimp would be a good combination."

  • KRUG: GRANDE CUVÉE NV $90: "All their still wines are aged in oak before the secondary fermentation. Makes for a bold flavor. Probably from six to 10 different vintages of their reserve wines are used to make this champagne, and I think it spent an average of 6 years on its yeast. which is why, in many cases, Krug Grand cuvée is as expensive as other houses' prestige champagnes. Though this is another classic recommendation with caviar, it's of such substance it could work well with foods ranging all the way up to red meat -- but food preparation is very important."

  • LAURENT PERRIER NV BRUT $27: "This is another one to me that has that classic biscuitiy aroma, crisp fruit, a little bit floral on the nose. Again this sometimes works as an aperitif on its own, though with food it would have to be very subtle because of its fragile violet aromas."

  • POL ROGER NON-VINTAGE "WHITE FOIL" $32: "Very balanced between their acidity and creamy/buttery textures. Since it's such a classic champagne I would want to recommend classic preparations -- cold shellfish, smoked salmon, caviar."

  • POMMERY: BRUT ROYAL NV $30:"Delicate, subtle nuances. A great aperitif wine."

  • LOUIS ROEDERER BRUT PREMIER NV $32, "A soft, rich texture. Serve early in the meal with cold preparations. A champagne with true acidity so it can work with many seafood preparations."

  • SALON $156: "A unique house that makes only one vintage Champagne. It was the house Champagne of Maxime's in Paris in the '20s. The ultimate luxury and richness. Another house that ages its wines usually 10 years before release. A perfect match for Beluga caviar."

  • TATTINGER LA FRANCAISE NV $35: "During an all-Champagne, all-Tattinger dinner at the Ritz when Pierre-Emmanual Tattinger was the guest of honor, we ended up serving sea-bass wrapped in braised lettuce as a main course. And Chef Sarah Stegner came through big time on that one. It really showed the versatility of this powerful, long lasting Champagne."

  • VEUVE CLIQUOT PONSARDIN YELLOW LABEL BRUT NV $33: "A very bold Champagne, ripe flavors. Serve with fish and lighter meats, guinea hen, partridge."
  • So I placed his list on the table, closed my eyes and pointed. When I opened my eyes, my finger had landed on Krug Grande cuvée, at $90 a 750 ml bottle, reminding me of the ancient Chinese proverb, "He who rides a tiger can never descend." It couldn't hurt my quest, I thought, to find out about the Krug style from the source, Caroline Krug, head of Krug's New York office. She wrote me, "For me the Krug style is first of all a life-style, a magic moment... As for the taste, I believe we can sum it up in one key word: harmony. Back in Reims, each step will help reaching this simple goal from the first fermentation in small oak casks (unique to Krug today) to the blending and the long aging in the bottle (6 years for our Grande cuvée Multi-Vintage). Year after year when my uncle Henri, my Dad, my cousin and I taste the clear wines, we look for the true personality of each individual with the memory of the previous Grande Cuvée...reaching complexity, depth, creaminess but the elegance, fruitiness, clean finish....I feel thirsty now!" So do I. And because she has reminded me that Krug Grande Cuvée comes in 375 ml bottles just right for two (at $60 the bottle), I'm off to my favorite wine merchant for a taste of style.

    How big? So big!
    When it comes to Champagne, one size does not fit all.
    1. 374 ml (milliliters). A half bottle. Just right for two.
    2. 750 ml* (milliliters). The familiar full bottle.
    3. Magnum. 1-1/2 liters. Two full bottles.
    4. Jeroboam. 3 liters. Four full bottles.
    5. Rehoboam. 4-1/2 liters. Six full bottles.
    6. Methuselah. 6 liters. Eight full bottles.
    7. Salmanazar. 9 liters. 12 full bottles.
    8. Balthazar. 12 liters. 16 full bottles.
    9. Nebuchadnezzar. 15 liters. 20 full bottles.

    *Please note that the secondary fermentation, which gives Champagne its bubbles, is commonly only done in 750 ml bottles.

    LIQUID ASSETS - November 2000

    BACK